I would assume from your post you consider yourself an above average weekend/day warrior, but I'm not entirely certain of the grading scale used here.

Regardless just because you find a snow drift in a tree well deep within the woods that took 4 hours to skin to that a hurricane gale force wind blew in doesn't mean that you can report it as a summit total is my point. I think you have to report the snowfall where people will be skiing. That works in both ways. We stay in a place on the Rox Gap Road for the season where we've woken up and had a dusting on our cars, but when we got to the mountain it was puking snow. I never trust the weather station reports because it's not necessarily where I'm skiing and small variations in location can have huge differences. However I do expect that if they report 12 inches on top then when I get off the Summit chair, Heaven's Gate or Castle Rock and look around I should see something remotely close or evidence that there might have been. On the day of my example they did caveat the whole thing saying that it was hard to tell because of the winds, but I would guess on that day they did not err on the side of caution. To be honest I'm highly dubious of reporting wind blow. If it did not drop from the sky put blew into a pile from the wind moving older snow around then it shouldn't count. I know it must be tough sorting that out, but on that day, after Josh Fox angered so many that entire week with his 79 feet of snow is coming, I felt like it was a marketing move. I was in the woods, trails, slack country, you name it. 4 inches was still a generous reporting for any where on the mountain. A foot was right out.
As I've said this is a rarity for the Bush who in my mind more often then not will underestimate the totals. That day in particular, after a week of the storm is coming mentality and the huge disappointment associated with it, it just stuck in my mind.